Email transcript 
Turn off sound
Mar 13, 2025
Table of ContentsThe Power of Notifications in Modern AppsWhat Are Push Notifications?What Are In-App Notifications?Key Differences Between In-App and Push NotificationsPush vs In-App Notifications: Which One Should You Use?How to Optimize Your Notification StrategyFinding the Right Notification Strategy
Table of ContentsThe Power of Notifications in Modern AppsWhat Are Push Notifications?What Are In-App Notifications?Key Differences Between In-App and Push NotificationsPush vs In-App Notifications: Which One Should You Use?How to Optimize Your Notification StrategyFinding the Right Notification Strategy
Late one evening, Sarah checks her phone. A notification pops up: "Your ride is arriving in 2 minutes." Minutes later, while using the app, a message appears at the top of her screen: "Rate your trip and earn bonus points!" Two different types of notifications, two different moments, one seamless experience.
This scenario plays out millions of times daily across countless apps. Behind these seemingly simple messages lies a strategic choice that can make or break user engagement: in-app vs push notifications. Getting this choice right means the difference between helpful reminders and annoying interruptions.
Today's users face a barrage of notifications from dozens of apps. Each ping, pop-up, and alert competes for precious attention. For businesses, this creates a delicate balance - stay too quiet, and users might forget your app exists; become too pushy, and they might hit that dreaded "disable notifications" button.
Gone are the days when apps could passively wait for users to remember them. In today's fast-paced digital world, the difference between in-app and push notifications can determine whether an app becomes a daily habit or joins the graveyard of forgotten downloads.
Think about your morning routine. Maybe it starts with a weather alert, followed by news headlines, then a reminder about that meeting you scheduled. Each notification serves a purpose, arriving through carefully chosen channels to catch you at the right moment.
Push notification and in-app notification strategies directly influence key business metrics. From boosting user retention to driving conversions, these communication tools have become essential weapons in the modern app marketing arsenal.
Push notifications are messages sent to a user’s device, appearing as alerts on their lock screen, notification center, or home screen. These notifications are designed to bring users back into an app and can be sent even when the app is closed.
Push notifications typically require users to opt in, meaning they must grant permission for an app to send them alerts. They can contain text, images, emojis, videos, and interactive buttons, allowing for a more engaging experience.
Push notifications work best for bringing users back to the app or providing real-time updates. Common use cases include:
Push notifications provide instant engagement, allowing businesses to reach users in real-time with important updates or offers. Since they appear directly on a user’s lock screen, they are highly effective at grabbing attention and encouraging immediate action. One of the biggest advantages of push notifications is their ability to bring users back into the app, making them a valuable tool for re-engagement campaigns.
Unlike in-app notifications, which require users to be active within the app, push notifications work even when the app is closed, making them a powerful method for driving conversions. Additionally, they are highly customizable, allowing businesses to include rich media elements like images, videos, and interactive buttons to enhance user experience and interaction.
Despite their effectiveness, push notifications come with some challenges that businesses must navigate. One major limitation is that they require user opt-in, meaning users must explicitly allow notifications before they can be received. Many users disable notifications due to concerns about spam or privacy, leading to lower reach. Additionally, push notifications can sometimes feel intrusive, especially if they are sent too frequently or at the wrong time, which may lead to annoyance, opt-outs, or even app uninstalls.
Another limitation is the character limit, as push notifications must be concise enough to fit within the notification space, making it challenging to deliver complex messages without losing clarity. Despite these challenges, when used strategically, push notifications remain one of the most effective tools for user engagement and app retention.
In-app notifications are messages displayed within the app while a user is actively using it. Unlike push notifications, they don’t require user opt-in and only appear when the app is open, making them a non-intrusive way to communicate with users. These notifications are commonly used to guide users, provide updates, or encourage engagement without disrupting their overall experience.
In-app notifications can take different forms, such as banners, pop-ups, tooltips, modals, or embedded messages. They help improve user experience by delivering contextual information at the right moment—whether it’s introducing a new feature, providing helpful tips, or prompting users to take action.
In-app notifications are best for enhancing engagement, improving user experience, and guiding users within the app. Common use cases include:
One of the biggest advantages of in-app notifications is that they don’t require user opt-in, meaning every active user can see them without needing prior permission. Since they only appear while the user is inside the app, they are less disruptive compared to push notifications, which can pop up at inconvenient times.
In-app notifications are particularly effective for boosting engagement, as they provide users with real-time updates, feature highlights, and personalized interactions that encourage deeper app usage. By delivering information in context, they help users navigate the app more effectively, complete actions, and stay informed without feeling overwhelmed by external distractions.
Despite their advantages, in-app notifications have some limitations. One key challenge is their limited reach, as they are only visible when a user is actively using the app. If a user doesn’t open the app frequently, they may miss important messages. Additionally, poorly designed in-app notifications can be easily ignored or dismissed, reducing their effectiveness.
If businesses overuse in-app notifications, they risk cluttering the user interface and frustrating users, leading to a negative experience rather than increased engagement. To be effective, in-app notifications should be well-timed, visually appealing, and relevant to the user’s actions within the app.
The table below highlights the major differences between in-app and push notifications to help businesses decide when to use each.
| Feature | Push Notifications | In-App Notifications |
|---|---|---|
| Visibility | Appears outside the app (lock screen, home screen, notification center) | Only visible when users are inside the app. |
| User Opt-in Required? | Yes, users must enable notifications | No, all users see them while using the app |
| Best For | Re-engagement, urgent updates, promotions, reminders | Onboarding, feature adoption, personalized recommendations, account-related messages |
| Delivery Timing | Can be sent at any time, even when the app is closed | Only appears when the app is actively in use |
| Interruption Level | Can interrupt users at any time, even when they are not using the app. | Only shown when the user is actively engaged in the app. |
| Personalization | Can be personalized based on user behavior and preferences. | Highly contextual, triggered by in-app actions. |
| User Engagement | Drives external engagement and app re-open rates. | Enhances in-app experience and interaction. |
Both push notifications and in-app notifications serve unique purposes, and the best choice depends on your goals, audience, and message type. Below are some scenario-based recommendations to help determine which notification type is best for different situations.
Absolutely! A hybrid notification strategy can maximize engagement by leveraging the strengths of both push and in-app notifications. Businesses can attract users back with push notifications and then enhance their experience inside the app with in-app notifications.
For example:
By combining both notification types, businesses can create a seamless and personalized experience that not only re-engages users but also encourages in-app actions, ultimately improving retention and conversion rates.
A well-crafted notification strategy can significantly improve user engagement and retention, but it requires careful planning and execution. Below are some key strategies to ensure that push and in-app notifications deliver maximum impact without overwhelming users.
Generic, one-size-fits-all notifications often get ignored or dismissed. Instead, tailor notifications based on user behavior, preferences, and past interactions. Personalization makes notifications feel more relevant, increasing the likelihood of engagement.
For example, a music streaming app can send a push notification like, "Your favorite artist just dropped a new album—listen now!", while an e-commerce app might remind a user about an abandoned cart with a personalized discount. The more relevant the message, the higher the engagement.
Sending too many notifications can overwhelm users and lead to opt-outs or app uninstalls. To avoid notification fatigue, space out messages and schedule them at optimal times. Consider user time zones, behavior patterns, and activity windows.
For instance, a fitness app might send a morning reminder like, "Start your day strong—time for your workout!", while a food delivery app might notify users around mealtimes with "Feeling hungry? Here’s a 20% discount on your next order!". Proper timing ensures that notifications are helpful rather than annoying.
Not all notifications perform equally well, so it’s important to track their effectiveness and adjust accordingly. Use A/B testing to compare different versions of a notification and identify what resonates most with users.
Experiment with different wording, timing, and formats—for example, testing whether a short push notification performs better than a longer, more detailed one. Analyze key metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates to refine your approach.
Notifications that contain emojis, images, videos, or GIFs tend to attract more attention than plain text messages. Rich media enhances the visual appeal of notifications, making them more engaging and interactive.
For instance, a travel app might use a stunning image of a vacation destination to promote travel deals, while a gaming app could send an animated GIF of a new character or reward. Using visuals makes notifications stand out and encourages users to take action.
Different users have different needs and preferences, so segmenting your audience ensures that each user receives relevant and meaningful notifications. Instead of sending the same message to all users, group users based on behavior, demographics, or engagement level.
For example, an e-commerce app could send exclusive offers to high-spending customers, while a news app might allow users to opt into specific categories like sports, politics, or entertainment. The more targeted the notifications, the higher the chances of engagement and conversion.
Both push and in-app notifications are essential for user engagement, but their effectiveness depends on how they’re used. Push notifications are great for re-engagement and time-sensitive updates, while in-app notifications enhance the user experience and guide interactions.
Rather than choosing one, businesses should combine both to create a balanced strategy. A push notification can bring users back, while an in-app notification ensures a smooth experience once they’re inside the app.
Success comes down to personalization, timing, and testing. Well-targeted notifications enhance engagement, while excessive or irrelevant ones can drive users away. By refining their approach, businesses can boost retention, increase conversions, and create a more engaging app experience.
Crafting the right notification strategy is essential for keeping users engaged, but delivering seamless, real-time messaging requires the right infrastructure. With Sceyt’s advanced in-app messaging solutions, you can enhance user engagement, deliver timely notifications, and create a frictionless communication experience within your app. Contact us to learn more!
Luis is a content writer with over 15 years of experience in scriptwriting, editing, and copywriting. He specializes in producing engaging content with a focus on delivering eye-opening results.
